by Agatha Christie
I'm behind on reading, as usual. This was actually the February book for #ReadChristie2026 and due to being uprooted by a temporary move, I just finally got to this one. And it was a good one.
After a wonderful dinner at a French restaurant, Hercule Poirot's gastronomic reveries go by the wayside when he returns home and finds Superintendent Spence of the Kilchester Police waiting for him. They once worked a case together and Spence has a favor to ask. It concerns the murder of a widowed charwoman whose supposed killer has just been convicted and will be hung. The problem is that even Spence, an experienced investigator, doesn't think they have the right man, although the evidence - collected by Spence himself - resulted in a quick conviction. Intrigued, Poirot agrees to take the case.
He heads to Broadhinny to round up the usual suspects, and as is usual in Christie's works, there is a large and colorful cast of characters/suspects. The convicted man himself is the most colorless, the type of person my Dad euphemistically referred to as "not one of life's winners." James Bentley was Mrs. McGinty's lodger, had lost his job and was two months behind in paying for his room. In addition to being murdered Mrs. McGinty's room had been ransacked and money taken and stashed in the yard. Bentley had no alibi other than he had been out walking on his own, nothing pointed to anyone else, and the jury was presented with what appeared to be an open and shut case. Bentley is also not very helpful, having resigned himself to his fate, but fortunately for him Poirot is determined to find Mrs. McGinty's real killer.
It turns out Mrs. McGinty wasn't killed for money, but for having discovered a dark secret about one of Broadhinny's residents. How Poirot, who himself feels frustrated during most of the investigation, determines the actual guilty party was a lot of fun. I got through it in just a couple of sittings. Definitely better than
January's experience.
One of the many things I really loved about this story was Poirot's musings on his love of good food and how he and Superintendent Spence celebrated solving the mystery with dinner back at the French restaurant from the beginning of the story.
The theme for Read Christie this year is Biggest, Best, Beloved, and Mrs. McGinty's Dead was picked for Beloved Character(s). Next month: Murder on the Orient Express. It's supposed to represent "Biggest Impact on You As A Young Reader" but believe it or not, I've never read it. I didn't really read mysteries as a young reader, I was buried in horse books. But it's a Poirot and I can't imagine not loving it, although I do already know the twist in its ending. But it's Poirot, and I do love him, so I'm looking forward to it.